Official Nintendo Magazine

Login to access exclusive Nintendo content, win prizes and post on our forums. Not a member yet? Register for free

Best 3DS games

Here are the top ten best 3DS games you can buy in the shops

Looking for a new game to play on your Nintendo 3DS. Look no further for here are the best 3DS games that are available to buy now in the shops.

10. Rhythm Thief And The Emperor's Treasure

Click to view larger image
Rhythm Thief is like Professor Layton with rhythm mini-games replacing the brainteasing puzzles. Playing as Raphael, you have to explore Paris and steal works of art in order to get to the bottom of your father's disappearance. With Napoleon Bonaparte rising from the dead, this sounds pretty daft, but with with breathtaking cutscenes and amazing music accompanying you as you tap and slide the stylus, you should give this serious consideration.

Read our Rhythm Thief And The Emperor's Treasure review for more.

9. Sonic Generations

Click to view larger image
Sonic couldn't quite manage to beat Mario to the crown of best 3DS platformer but he had a good go in this excellent game that sees Sonic doing what he does best - speeding through 2D levels, collecting rings, burning around loops and taking out enemies. The fact that it features levels from old 2D and 3D Sonic adventures adds to the nostalgia value for older gamers but this still feels fresh.

Read our Sonic Generations review for more.

8. Dead Or Alive Dimensions

Click to view larger image
It's hard to separate Dead Or Alive and Super Street Fighter IV 3D. Both games are classics of the beat 'em up genre, both do their best to get the most out of 3DS with StreetPass and online fighting but in the end the extra character of Capcom's brawler means it wins on points. If you want a pure fighting game without the fireballs and OTT special moves, Dead Or Alive Dimensions curvacious crew of fighters might be for you.

Read our Dead Or Alive Dimensions review for more.

7. Super Street Fighter IV 3D

Click to view larger image
Super Street Fighter IV 3D was a brilliant way to launch the 3DS. Capcom's fighting game was the best game in the 3DS launch line-up and it remains not only one of the greatest 3DS games but one of the best fighting games of all time. The impressive thing about is that has been near perfectly recreated from the HD consoles but it also added an new over-the-shoulder camera angle and an addictive figure collecting mode which sees you assembling figures to fight other players over StreetPass. The new touchscreen special moves make it more accessible for newcomers, too.

Read our Super Street Fighter IV 3D review for more.

6. Star Fox 64 3D

Click to view larger image
One of two N64 remakes in this top ten, Star Fox 64 3D reminds us of why we loved Fox McCloud and crew in the first place (although Slippy Toad is still annoying). After a few average games on GameCube and GBA, they returned for more space-shooting action armed with newly-polished visuals, accessible gyro controls and a great multiplayer mode.

Read our Star Fox 64 3D review for more.

Previous 1 2 Next page

Comments

90 comments so far...
Add a comment

  1. Grovyle Monday 26th Dec 2011 at 11:45

    I think residemt evil mercenaries should be in this because 1. its better than nintendogs and cats 2. it has online, absent from many a game and 3. the graphics are pretty amazing. So it should start at number 10 and slowly climb up untill it finds its place!

  2. Cinaclov Monday 26th Dec 2011 at 11:53

    Considering there's only about 60 or so 3DS games out at the moment, and with even fewer of them being that amazing, it can't have been that difficult to compile this list :P

  3. mr.AR Monday 26th Dec 2011 at 12:28

    Yeah, I do think that they are all in the right place there!!

  4. stealth1497 Monday 26th Dec 2011 at 12:59

    I think residemt evil mercenaries should be in this because 1. its better than nintendogs and cats 2. it has online, absent from many a game and 3. the graphics are pretty amazing. So it should start at number 10 and slowly climb up untill it finds its place!

    Totally agree 8)

  5. Smyrlie Monday 26th Dec 2011 at 14:24

    Good list but starfox shouldn't have been number 4. Am I the only one who didn't like this game? :?: I got it and completed the game in less than 2 and a half hours and the gameplay wasn't even good, it was just doing the same thing over and over again. :? Took it back the next day. Other than that no surprises in the list.

  6. Snarafe Monday 26th Dec 2011 at 15:01

    Tales of Abyss! That is all...

  7. Link16 Monday 26th Dec 2011 at 15:13

    Misleading title is misleading. Only 5 of those games are worth playing.

  8. Red-Wolf Monday 26th Dec 2011 at 15:20

    Street Fighter; greatest fighting game ever? Street Fighter; accessible for newcomers? ONM are experts at the old oxymorons aren't they?

  9. HughPR Monday 26th Dec 2011 at 17:47

    So SM3DL above MK7. How is the MK7 single-player, and will online be updated to make it better? Should I get SM3DL or MK7. I enjoy both genres, but want something to last a little while, although I'm doubtful as to whether I'll play much online.

  10. bennyt Monday 26th Dec 2011 at 18:57

    Ghost Recon Shadow Wars?

    May not be the best using the 3d effect, but its an overlooked gem.

    Currently, myself and my brother have got: SM3DL, MK7, PW: Resort and Nintendogs and we think...

    they'll all great

    Come 2012 and boy, will we have some top 10

  11. TheNUKEnukeM Monday 26th Dec 2011 at 21:00

    If you are going out looking for 3DS Games in the after christmas sales try Dead or Alive. Its a lot more accessible than street fighter because it only has One Punch Button and One Kick Button. The roster is attractive. And I Think it is the hidden classic of 3DS. And if you dont like it you can easily trade it, but i really like it.

  12. onm101 Monday 26th Dec 2011 at 22:21

    I got the Limited edition Zelda 3DS, with Ocarina of Time, and the limited edition Skyward Sword guide book, even though I'm on the Sky Keep :)

  13. MrChewtoy Monday 26th Dec 2011 at 22:46

    The top four are the only ones I want/have. Pilotwings and Rayman 3D are also pretty fun games!

  14. imbusydoctorwho Monday 26th Dec 2011 at 23:28

    I've got 9 on that list apart from Cave Story 3D,which you can't find anywhere in Game.

  15. GuitarHero Tuesday 27th Dec 2011 at 00:49

    I found Ridge Racer and Street Fighter both average games. With SM3DLand being slightly above average, meaning I would put MK7 first as I don't like the Zelda series.

  16. Murphy11 Tuesday 27th Dec 2011 at 09:37

    What about Super Pokemon Rumble? IT is an amazing game!

  17. colourblindyoshi Tuesday 27th Dec 2011 at 09:48

    so, the best game may allways be OOT 3D.

    street fighter deserves to be there, maybe higher.

    next year god knows. metal gear solid for the top anyone?

  18. tomutwit Tuesday 27th Dec 2011 at 19:10

    I got SM3DL for Christmas. It's pretty crap until world 5. then it gets kind of fun. nowhere near as good as galaxy. OOT 3D was really good but so was its source material! I want Mario Kart 7 bad! SSFIV is crap.

  19. PureAwesomeness Wednesday 28th Dec 2011 at 17:04

    'Top ten 3DS games'
    'Yet' at the end should have been added. Next year's games will be much better, and I imagine OoT 3D will be kicked off its 3DS perch sooner with the upcoming release of Kid Icarus: Uprising and Luigi's Mansion 2.

  20. wolflink97 Wednesday 28th Dec 2011 at 19:45

    I have the top 5 so, the others don't appeal to me, except sonic, i might buy it eventually! 8)

  21. Hisoka Wednesday 28th Dec 2011 at 21:31

    Sonic Generations and Cave Story 3D should be higher up the list.

    Perhaps Skylanders should be on the list? Even after all the flaws it has with having to get figures and having slightly lacklustre worlds, it's still one of the only decent 3d platformers around.

    Rayman 3D is just a lazy port of the dreamcast version of Rayman 2. Don't think we didn't notice Ubisoft! Give us Rayman Origins soon and all will be forgiven.

  22. Rabb3D Sunday 8th Jan 2012 at 16:03

    Tales of The Abyss?

  23. Groosenator Thursday 2nd Feb 2012 at 13:47

    Meh, personally I reckon Tales of The Abyss and RE: Mercenaries should have been in there, instead of Ridge Racer and Cave Story. Other than that, the list is pretty solid.

  24. Riverlution Thursday 2nd Feb 2012 at 14:32

    Tales of the abyss should have been in there. And ridge racer out.

    Also, Skyward Sword better than Ocarina? No chance...

  25. Amg12 Thursday 2nd Feb 2012 at 16:14

    Yeah, I do think that they are all in the right place there!!

    Correction: They aren't in the right place there...

  26. Amg12 Thursday 2nd Feb 2012 at 16:15

    What about Super Pokemon Rumble? IT is an amazing game!


    Yea, It's pretty good

  27. Keniahten Thursday 2nd Feb 2012 at 16:25

    I don't think that Ocarina of Time should be so high on the list because I don't think that it lived up to the hype. Everyone was talking about the best zelda game ever and when I played it I was kind of dissapointed. Also, I think Dead or alive should be higher. :)

  28. ThePokekid78 Thursday 2nd Feb 2012 at 16:38

    Is it really right to do a best 3ds games ever when the console's been out for less than a year? :lol:

  29. Pokemon Luke Thursday 2nd Feb 2012 at 18:07

    All Of You Please Calm Down! Skyward Sword Is Better Than Ocarina And Super Pokemon Rumble Should Be There Ok?

  30. Joshuabell11 Thursday 2nd Feb 2012 at 19:43

    Looking at those games makes me think how good a metroid prime game could be, or maybe even a remake of the beloved metriod prime for Gamecube

  31. imbusydoctorwho Thursday 2nd Feb 2012 at 20:57

    Super Pokemon Rumble Should Be There Ok?

    I have Super Pokemon Rumble and I do like it but I don't think it should be in the top ten,probably in the top 15.

    I do think Shinobi should be in there,brilliant game,if a bit hard.

  32. lrwr14 Thursday 2nd Feb 2012 at 21:35

    I don't think LoZ OoT should be number 1, to be truthful I don't think it should even be in the top 10. But seeing as there aren't many good games on the 3DS at the moment (or at least ones with a good storyline) I guess it could make it into the top 10.

  33. Dalekbuster523 Thursday 2nd Feb 2012 at 21:40

    Glad to see Sonic Generations,Mario Kart 7 and Super Mario 3D land have made this list. Great games but I think they should be higher up. I'd put Sonic Generations at number 3,Super Mario 3D land at NO2 and Mario Kart 7 NO1.

  34. Zephild Thursday 2nd Feb 2012 at 23:51

    Wouldn't make me buy a 3DS.

  35. ChrisONM Friday 3rd Feb 2012 at 10:11

    Street Fighter; greatest fighting game ever? Street Fighter; accessible for newcomers? ONM are experts at the old oxymorons aren't they?


    In what way are those oxymorons?

  36. Highlight Friday 3rd Feb 2012 at 10:45

    Street Fighter; greatest fighting game ever? Street Fighter; accessible for newcomers? ONM are experts at the old oxymorons aren't they?

    This is an example of someone who's heard a word but doesn't know what it means.

    'Top ten 3DS games'
    'Yet' at the end should have been added. Next year's games will be much better, and I imagine OoT 3D will be kicked off its 3DS perch sooner with the upcoming release of Kid Icarus: Uprising and Luigi's Mansion 2.

    Well obviously it's going to be "so far". Show me a list of best games for a console that's still in production that includes games yet to be released.

  37. paultheotherone Friday 3rd Feb 2012 at 12:00

    Street Fighter; greatest fighting game ever? Street Fighter; accessible for newcomers? ONM are experts at the old oxymorons aren't they?


    In what way are those oxymorons?

    To qualify an oxymoron is a phrase or sentence with presents two opposites. For example, the living dead is an oxymoron. Those sentences are in no way oxymoronic.

    I think SM3D personally should be number one, and Ghost Recon should be in there rather than Dogs. It was a great game which got me through the drought and the 3d effect was nice.

  38. Doomgnat Friday 3rd Feb 2012 at 19:39

    Its good to see LoZ at its rightful place as number one. :D

  39. RidgeRacer3Dfan Friday 3rd Feb 2012 at 22:38

    I have LoZ, SM3DL, MK7, Starfox, Street fighter and ridge racer
    i think fifa should be there if it had online cause i am playing it atm and loving it all except no online and rubbish transfer system

  40. liveswired Friday 3rd Feb 2012 at 23:15

    OOT is fantastic - but it is definitely NOT the best title on the 3DS.

    The creaky old n64 engine being pushed to breaking point with a mixed bag of remodelled areas and 3D wasn't that impressive. Grezzo could've at least been given the Twilight Princess engine - but then again it probably would've taken until now to release it - something Nintendo couldn't afford.

  41. wak Saturday 4th Feb 2012 at 10:45

    I'm amazed how often Ghost Recon gets overlooked when the 3DS games are debated. Yes visually it's not the best looking or uses the 3D effect to its potential but what it will do is keep you engrossed for 40+ hours, and not many 3DS games can boast that.

    Hopefully they will make a 3DS sequel and it will get the recognition it deserves.

  42. alexjones94 Saturday 4th Feb 2012 at 16:14

    Street Fighter; greatest fighting game ever? Street Fighter; accessible for newcomers? ONM are experts at the old oxymorons aren't they?


    In what way are those oxymorons?

    I think he was somehow trying to say that the greatest fighting game ever can't be accessible for newcomers. They're clearly not oxymorons though. Drop the "oxy" and you might be closer to the mark :wink:

  43. ridinglikesatan Friday 10th Feb 2012 at 09:06

    Love all of these games, can't fault the list at all :P Anyone know a good way of recording 3DS footage though? It would really help with Youtube videos

  44. keir Friday 10th Feb 2012 at 11:44

    I have 5 of the out of 10 best 3DS games and I have 1 demo from the NINTENDO e shop. :D

  45. Xenoblade Hero Friday 10th Feb 2012 at 13:59

    Both Revelations and Mercenaries were much better than 3D Land. I'm fine with Mario Kart 7 and OOT being in the top 3 though

  46. paultheotherone Friday 10th Feb 2012 at 14:43

    Both Revelations and Mercenaries were much better than 3D Land. I'm fine with Mario Kart 7 and OOT being in the top 3 though

    Surely not Mercenaries? The raid mode in Rev is better and what mercenaries always was: a side game.

  47. Tommson Wednesday 28th Mar 2012 at 16:19

    Good list, although I don't really agree with Ridge Racer or Sonic Generations being there, how about Tetris or Tekken 3D?

    Besides that it's pretty much exactly what I'd of put, also it feels good knowing I own almost all of them.

  48. ProtoKun Wednesday 28th Mar 2012 at 16:36

    I really can't see Ocarina 3D deserving the top spot… It's a wonderful game, mind you, but being over original games? It's a remake (or enhanced port, whichever you prefer). Mario 3D Land, Mario Kart 7, RE: Revelations are sequels to well known franchises and even had much more work involved, and Kid Icarus has proven to be a must-have title, and feels like a new IP despite the NES and GB games.

  49. ARWING64 Wednesday 28th Mar 2012 at 18:21

    The top 3 should go
    1. MK7
    2. SM3DL
    3. LoZ:OOT

    Ocarina of Time should not be number one as its a remake! Sure it is fantastic but MK7 is an original 3DS title and is superb.

  50. Retro_D64 Wednesday 28th Mar 2012 at 19:19

    Either Mario Kart 7 or Super Mario 3d Land, I wish they would make a pokemon 3ds game so that i could love that too

  51. NintyHippo Wednesday 28th Mar 2012 at 19:26

    My top three:

    1. Mario Kart 7
    2. Kid Icarus Uprising
    3. Super Mario 3D Land

  52. Rokinaus Wednesday 28th Mar 2012 at 21:39

    Did they really call Ridge Racer 3D better than Pilotwings Resort? Pilotwings was a great game! Sure it was light on modes and content, but the gameplay was solid and the graphics were beautiful!

  53. KingToAD Wednesday 28th Mar 2012 at 21:59

    I'm Sorry but guys, Kid Icarus: uprising has got to be Number 1. As much as I love LOZ OOT, Uprising is brand new adventure with soooo much to offer. It has it all, online, collectibles and a fab solo mode, not to mention the highly addictive trading card collection. Uprising has not only got me wanting more but it's also got my star points in on the action and we all know how much action they usually get!

  54. sciqueen Thursday 29th Mar 2012 at 10:13

    OoT is the best N64 game, not the best 3DS game: that goes to SM3DL or Kid Icarus.

  55. MartinIsAwesome Thursday 29th Mar 2012 at 10:23

    Good list, although I don't really agree with Ridge Racer or Sonic Generations being there, how about Tetris or Tekken 3D?

    Couldn't disagree more on the Sonic Generations point. The only downside to it is that the main story mode too short. Otherwise, the game is solid.

  56. imbusydoctorwho Thursday 29th Mar 2012 at 13:00

    Kid Icarus Uprising is the future of Nintendo.

  57. abovethewell Tuesday 8th May 2012 at 17:04

    Is it just where I live (Up North) or are 3ds games really hard to find in shops? In the game in Preston, They hardly have any, with the ones they do have either being big 1st party games or launch games... No Cave story, no bit trip, no rhythm theif... What is the reason for this?

  58. Dertdood Tuesday 8th May 2012 at 17:19

    Kid Icarus and Resident Evil deserve a higher place, Mario 3DLand shouldn't even be on there

  59. benandarchie Tuesday 8th May 2012 at 17:20

    true but zelda ocarina of time shouldnt be in the top 10 at all.

  60. OracleOfPokemon Tuesday 8th May 2012 at 17:37

    Good list but starfox shouldn't have been number 4. Am I the only one who didn't like this game? :?: I got it and completed the game in less than 2 and a half hours and the gameplay wasn't even good, it was just doing the same thing over and over again. :? Took it back the next day. Other than that no surprises in the list.

    I agree, Star Fox was utter crap. Also, Kid Icarus is obviously the best 3DS out, a million times better than OOT 3D. Ocarina 3D was just too boring and nowhere as epic as Twilight Princess.

  61. LegendofD Tuesday 8th May 2012 at 18:23

    Tales of the Abyss deserves a place in my opinion :) I think Kid Icarus Uprising should have been in 1st, Although Oot has better gameplay, It does not use any of the 3DS's wireless features.

  62. Argenthor Tuesday 8th May 2012 at 18:50

    Street Fighter; greatest fighting game ever? Street Fighter; accessible for newcomers? ONM are experts at the old oxymorons aren't they?


    That they are. That they are.

  63. linkfinity Tuesday 8th May 2012 at 19:17

    super mario 3d land has been far too highly ranked in this, as onm seem to do with all mario games.
    it's not as good or even close to resident evil: revelations or kid Icarus: uprising.

  64. Targey Tuesday 8th May 2012 at 20:51

    > 9. Sonic Generations (3DS)

    That's hilarious, ONM. Seriously though, where's the game that's actually supposed to be there?

    ... Oh, you were being serious.

  65. me4ndubz Tuesday 8th May 2012 at 21:16

    i have the top 4 :)

  66. MartinIsAwesome Wednesday 9th May 2012 at 09:27

    > 9. Sonic Generations (3DS)

    That's hilarious, ONM. Seriously though, where's the game that's actually supposed to be there?

    ... Oh, you were being serious.

    If anything it should be higher in my opinion. Sure it's short but its loads of fun, and the missions and online mode add loads of longevity.

  67. Targey Wednesday 9th May 2012 at 13:35

    > 9. Sonic Generations (3DS)

    That's hilarious, ONM. Seriously though, where's the game that's actually supposed to be there?

    ... Oh, you were being serious.

    If anything it should be higher in my opinion. Sure it's short but its loads of fun, and the missions and online mode add loads of longevity.

    If I made this list, it wouldn't be on there. At all.

    It's short, definitely. It's not fun, though. Generations seems to suffer from the same flaws Sonic Rush had, where enemies pop out from nowhere, leaving you no time to react because you gotta go fast, and having bottomless pits everywhere to imply a false sense of difficulty. The pits are a joke; I think it's rather embarrassing when you have to point out to the player where these are, especially when they're several metres long. Whatever happened to good level design in Sonic games? They seem to just fade away during Sonic & Knuckles, and only ever resurface again for Sonic Advance. Also, this game can take the cake with Goddamn QTEs. One example is in Mushroom Hill Act 2, where if you don't respond to it within 0.25 seconds you die. Remember when these moments would be more forgiving, and simply just lead you to a slower route? Sonic Team seems to have forgotten this, though to be honest they've simply just forgotten how to make a decent title for the blue blur. I was about to say how I hope Sonic 4 Episode II could prove me wrong, but every time I make a statement like that I regret saying so.

  68. Komodo_Wolfgang Wednesday 9th May 2012 at 14:08

    Ghost Recon Shadow Wars?

    May not be the best using the 3d effect, but its an overlooked gem.

    Same with Samurai Chronicles >.> and uses pretty much all the 3DS has to offer.

  69. Komodo_Wolfgang Wednesday 9th May 2012 at 14:13

    Tales of the Abyss deserves a place in my opinion :) I think Kid Icarus Uprising should have been in 1st, Although Oot has better gameplay, It does not use any of the 3DS's wireless features.

    Im a huge Zelda fan, its joint 1st of my favourite franchises with pokemon.


    But I agree. Ocarina is the same, just in 3D...and thats all it offers really.

    Icarus covers everything brilliantly (sept the wifi doesnt seem to like me much and disconnects alot..and I do think its a bit repetative).

  70. imbusydoctorwho Wednesday 9th May 2012 at 14:21

    Metal Gear Solid 3 Snake Eater should be in the top 10.

    Here's my top ten 3DS games.
    1.Kid Icarus Uprising
    2.Ocarina Of Time 3D
    3.Mario 3D Land
    4.Mario Kart 7
    5.Star Fox 64 3D
    6.Dead or Alive Dimensions
    7.Resident Evil Revelations
    8.Metal Gear Solid 3 Snake Eater 3D
    9.Rhythm Thief and the Emperors Treasure
    10.Sonic Generations.

  71. Kirluigiicarus Wednesday 9th May 2012 at 15:12

    What happened to snake eater???? :shock:
    i love that game im stuck on THE END boss though

  72. alexkinch Wednesday 9th May 2012 at 15:37

    For me top 5 are kid icarus, snake eater, oot, resident evil rev and tales if abyss. Not that you could walk into a shop and get it but tales of abyss is epic.

  73. alexkinch Wednesday 9th May 2012 at 15:43

    What happened to snake eater???? :shock:
    i love that game im stuck on THE END boss though


    Thermal goggles and shoot his bird asap.

  74. Redfish20 Wednesday 9th May 2012 at 15:54

    at number 8 Dead Or Alive Dimensions

    "It's hard to separate Dead Or Alive and Super Street Fighter IV 3D. Both games are classics of the beat 'em up genre, both do their best to get the most out of 3DS with StreetPass and online fighting but in the end the extra character of Capcom's brawler means it wins on points."

    at number 7 Super Street Fighter IV 3D

    perhaps I misunderstood what you mean by "the extra character of Capcom's brawler means it wins on points."?

  75. Pyron12 Wednesday 9th May 2012 at 16:16

    1. Ocarina of Time 3D
    2. Mario Kart 7
    3. SM3DL
    Why did mk7 be lower than 3D land when Mario Kart has online and local multiplayer :?:

  76. carnivine chaos Wednesday 9th May 2012 at 16:37

    Let's be honest, this shouldn't be called "Top ten best 3DS games", this should just be titled "3DS games". These games are all there is to the console, 2 of which are remakes, and some being okay but not great.

  77. Diddy ZX Wednesday 9th May 2012 at 16:43

    Tut tut, guys - there were no Star Fox games for the GBA at all! ;)

    Anyway, if I had to name my top ten retail 3DS games so far (bearing in mind that many games to my taste that I'm waiting for aren't out yet), they'd be;

    10: Rayman 3D
    9: Ridge Racer 3D
    8: Rabbids 3D
    7: Super Mario 3D Land
    6: Pilotwings Resort
    5: Cave Story 3D
    4: Star Fox 64 3D
    3: Mario Kart 7
    2: Skylanders: Spyro's Adventure
    1: Kid Icarus: Uprising

    Some of them were pretty close and it was difficult to decide their order, but I think that I'm happy with the list. :P

  78. Commandervideo Wednesday 9th May 2012 at 17:10

    How is Mario 3Dland better than MK7?

    1 Mario kart 7
    2 Star fox 64
    3 Kid icarus uprising
    4 Zelda ocarina of time
    5 Super Mario 3D Land

  79. MartinIsAwesome Wednesday 9th May 2012 at 17:56

    If I made this list, it wouldn't be on there. At all.

    It's short, definitely. It's not fun, though. Generations seems to suffer from the same flaws Sonic Rush had, where enemies pop out from nowhere, leaving you no time to react because you gotta go fast


    Firstly, Sonic Rush is great so that's not much of an arguement. Second, I've never been hindered by an enemy popping out of nowhere, so I don't what you're talking about. Besides even if that was the case, that's what the Boost is for. You just plow straight through them anyway.

    and having bottomless pits everywhere to imply a false sense of difficulty. The pits are a joke; I think it's rather embarrassing when you have to point out to the player where these are, especially when they're several metres long. Whatever happened to good level design in Sonic games?They seem to just fade away during Sonic & Knuckles, and only ever resurface again for Sonic Advance.


    I hate this arguement that pitfalls = bad level design. It used to mean that games were hard, requiring photographic memory of the layout so that you didn't fall for those traps. Take Mega Man for example, inparticular that level in Mega Man 2 where the room fills with death-lasers as you plummit. Now, there's only two ways of clearing that: 1) stupid luck, or 2) using your brain to memorise where the openings are so that you don't get caught. It's a mental challenge and as far as I'm concerned should never be called "a joke".

    Also, this game can take the cake with Goddamn QTEs. One example is in Mushroom Hill Act 2, where if you don't respond to it within 0.25 seconds you die. Remember when these moments would be more forgiving, and simply just lead you to a slower route? Sonic Team seems to have forgotten this, though to be honest they've simply just forgotten how to make a decent title for the blue blur. I was about to say how I hope Sonic 4 Episode II could prove me wrong, but every time I make a statement like that I regret saying so.


    Maybe you're just a little bit rubbish? Just putting it out there.

  80. Diddy ZX Wednesday 9th May 2012 at 18:01

    Now, there's only two ways of clearing that: 1) stupid luck, or 2) using your brain to memorise where the openings are so that you don't get caught.


    Or quick reflexes (how I got through it the first time I ever set foot in that level), or, much much easier, using the correct weapon to freeze the beams.

    Anyway, please pardon me! I'm a Mega Man nut, and I just wanted to point out that there are two other methods of clearing it. :)

  81. Targey Wednesday 9th May 2012 at 20:41

    Firstly, Sonic Rush is great so that's not much of an arguement.

    Sonic Rush is okay, the main problem with the game is that you can literally just boost through everything. Until some enemy which, for some reason, is impervious to something running into it at a few hundred miles an hour and knocks a few rings out of you. This practically destroys any sense of challenge the developers wanted to make, and also makes the game less exciting that it could have been.

    I hate this arguement that pitfalls = bad level design.

    Pitfalls are okay when they're implemented well, but they rarely are in recent Sonic games. Remember that in the earlier games, bottomless pits barely showed up until either later levels, or when they suited the zone. Notice how in Classic Sonic's Mushroom Hill there are no pitfalls, but in Modern's there are. Why? Surely they should share similar attributes due to being in the same environment?

    Maybe you're just a little bit rubbish? Just putting it out there.

    Nice. Try and mock my gaming abilities because you know you can't make a decent argument for QTE's. I don't see why I should bother when the other person realises, "Oh God, I don't know how to respond to that. I know, I'll claim he's crap at the game. Problem solved!"

  82. MartinIsAwesome Wednesday 9th May 2012 at 21:50

    Now, there's only two ways of clearing that: 1) stupid luck, or 2) using your brain to memorise where the openings are so that you don't get caught.


    Or quick reflexes (how I got through it the first time I ever set foot in that level), or, much much easier, using the correct weapon to freeze the beams.

    Anyway, please pardon me! I'm a Mega Man nut, and I just wanted to point out that there are two other methods of clearing it. :)


    No, no, your right. I completely forgot about the time-freezing strategy. My bad.

    Maybe you're just a little bit rubbish? Just putting it out there.

    Nice. Try and mock my gaming abilities because you know you can't make a decent argument for QTE's. I don't see why I should bother when the other person realises, "Oh God, I don't know how to respond to that. I know, I'll claim he's crap at the game. Problem solved!"


    I'm not trying to mock your gaming abilities. I'm being quite blatant. I mean, I had no problem with it what so ever with the QTEs. There are a number of them in the game, and I've never failed any of them and they are not at all unforgiving. Like Diddy ZX mention, quick reactions are a legitimate and key skill to have. That's why they're called Quick Time Events. So I stand by my remarks.

  83. Targey Wednesday 9th May 2012 at 22:04

    I rarely fail them either, only on some of the first times I encounter them. I just dislike the idea of "Press X to not die" style gameplay when it can be easily avoided.

    Anyway, I forgot to mention things other than the gameplay. Level choices make no sense to me; the 3DS version is supposed to celebrate the handheld history somewhat, yet the console rendition does that simply by having more music from these games. You have Water Palace from Rush, and technically Tropical Resort from Colours (though it seems to be more like the Wii version's), but why not include levels from the Advance series? Moving on from that, Sonic Adventure 2's level wasn't even Sonic's in the first place, but rather Shadow's. My guess was this was so it fitted in with the boss fight with him, but if that's the case, why the heck do you fight Metal Sonic in Casino Night? And why, when you don't include a stage from Sonic Heroes, do you use a boss from that game? Why not one from Sonic Rush?

    I was thinking of mentioning the short length, but realise someone would mention the missions. But then I realise I'll just ask the question of what is the point. So I can look at some more pictures that can be found on the internet? It's not like the missions in the console versions, which unlock you news skills and items such as the elemental shields. I appreciate some people like that sort of content, being able to see the concept art and so on, but I prefer it when the unlockable content can affect the game, e.g. in Mario Kart 7, where new kart pieces unlocked can allow you to devise a better vehicle for time trials and so on.

  84. liveswired Wednesday 9th May 2012 at 23:56

    Ocarina of Time may well be a top ten 3DS game, but it is certainly NOT the best.

    I differ from ONM take - I feel that they didn't improve it enough - its the exact same OOT engine right down to the slow down - the difference being the new assets, higher resolution textures, a few added frames of animation and 3D - it's running on emulation. Grezzo didn't even bother upgrading a number of NPCs or their textures.

    Hyrule field is a disappointment, they could've done more with it, added a bit more life, vegetation, texture to spruce it up - as are the the lack of camera control options.

  85. MartinIsAwesome Thursday 10th May 2012 at 10:39

    @ Targey - With regard to the level choices, I'm not sure the game is geared towards being a handheld tribute. I always saw the inclusion of Water Palace as a refernce to it being a Nintendo exclusive. Also with regard to Radical Highway's inclusion, you may not be aware of this, but early in Sonic Adventure 2's development there were screenshots of Sonic in Shadow's exclusive levels, and Sonic was playable in the stage in the 2 Player mode. For me, being able to play as Sonic in one of my favourite SA2 stages is a fan-boy's dream come true. Sure I would have prefered City Escape, but I'm happy with the alternative.
    I agree with you that it would have been nice to include stages to represent the Advance games and Heroes. I think Egg Emperor was includes to reprent that game, like Big Arm represents Sonic 3, and Metal Sonic and Silver represent CD and '06 respectively.
    And yeah, I'm one of those people that like seeing the development material, but I would have liked the Missions even if there was no unlockables. I like them for the challenge and variety.

  86. SonicFreak Friday 11th May 2012 at 20:38

    Whilst I agree that yes this probably is the general top ten, my personal number one is Kid Icarus. Ocarina of time lost me quickly and Kid Icarus kept me hooked

  87. superdudemiles Saturday 12th May 2012 at 01:47

    yeh Mario 3dLand is Second! Im glad you put it there! I think its most likely the most undderated Mario game imo

  88. rabbidlime Saturday 12th May 2012 at 12:05

    Got 1-6 of those :D seems like my tastes match those of ONM 8)

  89. I Am Error Saturday 12th May 2012 at 14:17

    lol in this and best e shop games i have 5 of the ten games :shock: :D

  90. berniemad Saturday 12th May 2012 at 17:50

    I think LoZ: Ocarina of Time definitely deserves it's top spot but I do think Resident Evil should have been higher up.

Register or log in to commment
Add a comment

Login

Register

Not a member yet? Register now to access exclusive gaming content, win prizes and post on our forums.