Official Nintendo Magazine

Log in to access exclusive Nintendo content, win prizes and post on our forums. Not a member yet? Join for free

Hana Samurai: Art Of The Sword review

"This game is, like, seriously awesome" - Traditional Japanese Proverb

Fencing is beautiful. Where a gunfight's trademark is destruction, hosing an area with bullets in the hope that one hits a fleshier surface than wall, its pointy equivalent is more artistic. Every swing is measured, not necessarily intended to hit, but to allow for a future strike. It seems odd, then, that gaming rarely makes use of the feeling that flashing steel inspires: in the last few years we've had Skyward Sword and, well, Red Steel. That's about it.

So it's all the more unlikely - and wonderful - that a serious contender for the title of best sword fighting game in recent history comes from the 3DS eShop. Hana Samurai distils the essence of classic swordplay into a three-button action game. It's as simple as that and is all the better for it.

Click to view larger image
Its heart lies in third-person battle-morsels against multiple enemies. In stereotypically Japanese fashion, each opponent attacks one at a time and, with the exception of boss fights, these encounters almost always follow a similar pattern - they rush, you dodge (press B and a direction) or block (old L or R), then strike (press A) until they fall.

This sounds simplistic, but the beauty of the battle system is in how it prevents any attempt to break its thoughtful, skilful approach. You can't hack and slash because every failed attack slowly blunts your sword, making successful forays less effective. You can't constantly block for the same reason. Dodging is your best option, but every enemy type attacks differently, only given away by physical and vocal tells that will alert you to when and how you're about to be attacked.

Then there are the various rewards for playing the game particularly well - a precision rating based on successive last minute dodges (and reset to zero if you block or get struck), as well as the fact that a better dodge enables you to strike more times before an enemy can block again, consequently building a bar that allows you unleash your only attack which can hit multiple enemies. Even the 3D serves a function, helping you to gauge your distance from enemies' attacks.

Feedback Loop

Everything in the system affects another part of the system, and grasping all of this is massively important when it comes to boss battles, lengthier fights set after some unforgivingly checkpoint-free levels. It's brilliant and unlike almost any other game out right now. In fact, the best comparison for it is Punch-Out!!'s calculated fighting style, which brings us on to another little touch we enjoy: the game's homage to classic Nintendo series.

Click to view larger image
Travelling around the overworld is a matter of using a map that will be immediately familiar to any Mario or classic Zelda fan. Shops are taken straight from Link's N64 outings and the hurriedly explained storyline of a lone samurai searching for a captured princess is made more recognisable when vanquished bosses tell you that you might want to check another castle to find her.

The only real problem is, unfortunately, a big one; this game is very, very short. Nearly £7 gets you just about three hours of story mode; it all ends just as you're mastering battles. An unlockable Expert mode and some standalone marathon fights go some way to extending the experience, but it's not enough.

It's a shame, because this is one of the best eShop games we've come across. Hana Samurai's length makes it seem like an experiment in how to pull off a sword fighting game and it's a resounding success: now give us the full version.

Comments

7 comments so far...
Add a comment

  1. master sword Wednesday 17th Oct 2012 at 14:42

    It's the same with 'Liberation Maiden', both are fantastic in both presentation and Gameplay, but they're both just way too short :(

  2. Pyron12 Wednesday 17th Oct 2012 at 15:20

    It's the same with 'Liberation Maiden', both are fantastic in both presentation and Gameplay, but they're both just way too short :(


    The same also applies to Rhythm Thief and so many other games.

  3. Slinkington Wednesday 17th Oct 2012 at 15:58

    The game looks pretty good, but I really don't like the main character's design. Still, I wish I had bought this instead of Dillon's Rolling Western as I really didn't like that game.

  4. MartinIsAwesome Wednesday 17th Oct 2012 at 16:40

    It's the same with 'Liberation Maiden', both are fantastic in both presentation and Gameplay, but they're both just way too short :(


    I recently wrote a review for Liberation Maiden in the Reviews section of the forum and said exactly the same thing, albiet in spectaularly long winded fashion.

    I think that Hana Samurai looks very good though despite it's flaws, and seems like fun. Hopefully, like Liberation Maiden it has a score-attack side to it that gives it some extra replay value. Maybe Reviewtiful Joe can clear that up for me?

  5. Jazzer94 Wednesday 17th Oct 2012 at 17:33

    It really is a good game just a bit to short, also the last boss is way to difficult (tried 10 times at time of writing this and still haven't beaten him). :cry:

  6. KairiZero Thursday 18th Oct 2012 at 12:07

    This looks like it could be fun! SquareEnix need to get their finger out and bring Bushido Blade kicking and screaming onto the 3DS I think, that would be amazing!

  7. alexjones94 Friday 26th Oct 2012 at 16:06

    I think the fact that this has come to 3DS, rather than Wii, is a blessing in disguise. Free from inaccurate motion-waggling, it looks like the game Red Steel should've been. Before reading this review, I'd passed the game off as my most loathed game genre - the hack and slash - but I might just give it a go now.

    PS. It's nice to see Joe getting some decent games now and then. Remember Chandra, the occasional good game will make his anger more potent when he does get given a dud. :lol:

Register or log in to commment
Add a comment
Nintendo Co., Ltd. is the owner of certain copyright which subsists and trade marks and other intellectual property rights in certain content, characters, artwork, logos, scripts and representations used in this publication. All rights are expressly recognised and they are used by Future Publishing Limited under licence © 2006 Nintendo Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. "Nintendo", "International Nintendo Licensed Product" "Nintendo DS", "Nintendo DS Lite", "Nintendo DSi", "Nintendo 3DS", "Nintendo DSi XL", "Nintendo 3DS XL", "Wii" and "Wii U" and the associated logos are the trademarks of Nintendo Co. Ltd. All rights reserved.