Official Nintendo Magazine

Log in to access exclusive Nintendo content, win prizes and post on our forums. Not a member yet? Join for free

Tiger Woods PGA Tour 10 Review

Has EA Sports managed to sort out its putting problems?

Where one EA Sports game released last month(Grand Slam Tennis) evokes hazy notions of summery evenings spent being sworn at by stressed out tennis players, another, Tiger Woods PGA Tour 10, is happy to let the heavens dump their load on us as they see fit. Real time weather effects are one of the key new features of this latest Tiger, but while teeing off in whipping winds or lashing rain is rather cool, that is by no means the main hook. That comes from Wii MotionPlus, the new control scheme which maps your control input almost exactly 1:1 and creates the most realistic golf swing yet seen in a Tiger game.

Yes, you may be thinking that the club goes up and then back down - what is there to improve? And you're right. If you were to hide the person playing any Tiger game and concentrate on the action on-screen, you'd be hard-pushed to tell the difference between successive editions. However there's a big giveaway with Tiger 10, and that's the stuttering swing of the new player. Wii MotionPlus's input is such that it highlights every flaw in your approach to golf. As with Grand Slam Tennis, early forays into this brave, brutally honest new world of control are painful affairs at first.

Click to view larger image
If you've ever entertained the notion of being decent at golf, be prepared to have your bubble punctured. Wii MotionPlus is so sensitive that every minor hesitation shows up in your swing, cutting your power and leaving you some way short of the fairway.

Slickdraw McDraw

The big draw of Wii MotionPlus is literally big draw (and fade). Rolling your wrists as you push through your swing on contact with the ball adds spin and swerve to your shot, allowing you to better negotiate tricky courses. Trees, water hazards and bunkers can be better avoided if you get the skill just right, so you can approach the differing challenges offered by each hole in a subtly new way each time. Plus there's a simple satisfaction to be had from seeing your shot curl around a clump of trees half a mile in the distance.

It's a confidence thing. You need to make sure you're totally comfortable with your swing before attempting tricky courses and tournaments. Take Bethpage Black, the home of this year's US Open. The tournament is by its very nature one of the hardest of the year, and this year's is no different. A course full of traps for the unwary, its numerous bunkers will snaffle up even slightly misjudged shots. The prospect of playing it is daunting enough, so you need to have a slickly-oiled swing in perfect working order. Luckily that's the beauty of the game - despite early setbacks you'll want to hone and refine your game, because even the smallest improvement yields exciting results. The dangling carrot of Seve Ballesteros-levels of golfing genius spurs on your donkey-like golfer.

Click to view larger image

Gone Ka-putt?

Unfortunately putting is still too random in feel. Far too often we practised our putting (by holding A and B at the same time - B on its own swings your club for real), matching the suggested power level almost exactly, only to attempt the real thing and see the ball rocket ten feet past the hole. We tried at different distances from the sensor bar to see if that affected it, but to no avail. It's not a constant menace. For the most part putting works as smoothly as driving and chipping but there's the odd instance where you'll have played an absolute blinder to get to the pin in two shots, only to fluff your birdie chance and end up dropping two. When it comes to multiplayer, one of the highlights is the Play The Pros mode, in which you enter a real-time tournament and see your efforts compared with real-life players.There's about a 15 minute lag between playing a shot and seeing it posted online, and all of the assists are barred so you're competing 'equally'. Good, solid stuff.

If only the putting was more consistent. If it were, this would be as essential as Grand Slam Tennis. Having said that, it's still a fine effort, and Wii MotionPlus means the Wii version is the best game of Tiger around.

Comments

10 comments so far...
Add a comment

  1. snes2 Thursday 2nd Jul 2009 at 13:44

    I never liked golf games so i wont be getting this

    yay first post

  2. chino40k Friday 3rd Jul 2009 at 12:10

    I never liked golf games so i wont be getting this

    yay first post

    pointless comment of the day. well done.

    I got last years tiger woods which was excellent, I don't like to buy yearly sequels as usually one is enough but motion+ is a good reason to buck that trend I think. Other reviewers seem to think the putting is good again, although I never had issues with last years but its all opinions at the end of the day.

  3. MailToad94 Monday 6th Jul 2009 at 08:31

    Have absolutely no trouble with the putting.

  4. higson1983 Monday 13th Jul 2009 at 14:26

    To be honest, I dont particularly like golf, but I love a good golf game. No collection is complete without one. I used to love Tiger Woods on PC, but since then all golf games have seemed to be a bit complex and so I have never got on with them. When We Love Golf came out, due to recommendations by said magazine, I bought it and have never got on with it. Its not the cartoony style or anything, its just not ........good (maybe I need to give it more time). For this reason, I cant decide whether to get this (as I also feel bit let down by grand slam tennis). Perhaps wait until I see it in bargain bins everywhere for Ł5 like we love golf

  5. Jay_Magic Wednesday 15th Jul 2009 at 11:11

    ...I am genuinely surprised that this didnt get higher than 81%. The game is absolutely amazing! Cannot wait to get home and play it.

  6. N.A.T.O Monday 10th Aug 2009 at 20:14

    What a ridiculous review! I'm sorry but the putting is spot on. With M+ This is the ultimate virtual game of golf. This is a high 90's game.

    I urge everyone to purchase it, and disregard ONM's comments about the putting.

  7. xs3mx Thursday 13th Aug 2009 at 18:16

    ONM

    I Urge You To Change The Score As You Have In The Past.

    This Deserves 90+ & I Had No Trobule With Putting.

    Also Last Years Got 85% And This Got 81 When You Say Its The Best Version Yet

    Eplain Tht

  8. xs3mx Thursday 13th Aug 2009 at 18:16

    ONM

    I Urge You To Change The Score As You Have In The Past.

    This Deserves 90+ & I Had No Trobule With Putting.

    Also Last Years Got 85% And This Got 81 When You Say Its The Best Version Yet

    Eplain Tht

  9. MiniFats01 Friday 4th Dec 2009 at 09:56

    Do you have to use motion+?
    Can you just plug in a Gamecube or classic controller?
    That way, there wouldn't be any problems...

  10. Hardware128k Thursday 11th Feb 2010 at 21:32

    This game is awesome! Ther I've said it! Yeah, at times it can be bloody frustrating, but if you've ever played real golf, with real clubs and balls and everything (crap jumper not a necessity) then you'll know that, at times it can be bloody frustrating! So for so acurately recreating the game of golf, this really should of scored 90+.

Register or log in to commment
Add a comment
Nintendo Co., Ltd. is the owner of certain copyright which subsists and trade marks and other intellectual property rights in certain content, characters, artwork, logos, scripts and representations used in this publication. All rights are expressly recognised and they are used by Future Publishing Limited under licence © 2006 Nintendo Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. "Nintendo", "International Nintendo Licensed Product" "Nintendo DS", "Nintendo DS Lite", "Nintendo DSi", "Nintendo 3DS", "Nintendo DSi XL", "Nintendo 3DS XL", "Wii" and "Wii U" and the associated logos are the trademarks of Nintendo Co. Ltd. All rights reserved.